The government is concerned about the problem of leakage from employer-provided retirement plans, and hardship withdrawals (along with unpaid loans) are a big sources of leakage.
Now, it appears the Department of Labor and IRS may be cracking down on plans that do not follow strict requirements for authorizing permitted hardship withdrawals.
This creates an opportunity for advisors to help plan sponsors review plan document language and procedures in this area. A useful starting point is an IRS FAQ: www.irs.gov/Retirement-Plans/Retirement-Plans-FAQs-regarding-Hardship-Distributions
Recommended For You
Here are a few key points you may want to communicate to plan sponsors:
-
Plans are not required to offer any hardship withdrawals. If hardship withdrawals are offered, the plan document must describe specific criteria used to make hardship determinations. It's possible to fix past mistakes by amending plan documents ASAP.
-
Employers must have a process in place to verify that the employee requesting the withdrawal meets the law's requirement for an immediate and heavy financial need. In a list of "Do's and Don'ts," the IRS says employers should obtain specific ocumentation to verify the hardship. www.irs.gov/Retirement-Plans/Do's-and-Don'ts-of-Hardship-Distributions
-
The employer also must also document that the employee has exhausted any loans or resources available including insurance, bank accounts, and commercial/bank loans. Participants generally should suspend making elective deferrals to the plan, before taking hardship withdrawals.
-
The amount of a hardship withdrawal may not exceed the amount needed to meet the immediate and heavy need. Also, the withdrawal is limited to the employee's cumulative elective contributions only, and may not include any earnings or employer contributions.
Given the increased regulatory scrutiny and compliance liabilities, small 401(k) plans may want to consider whether it still makes sense to permit hardship withdrawals.
If the plan sponsor wants to continue offering hardship withdrawals, suggest using information from the IRS publications linked above to beef up participant education about hardship withdrawals, especially during enrollment.
© 2025 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.