The worst kind of surprise

Sometimes, providers will purposefully be out of network to abuse the dysfunctional system currently in place.While the charges may cost you a lot at the moment, it also translates to significantly higher premiums overall for a medical plan; hence the need for it to be controlled.

By Rachel Miner | March 24, 2021 at 08:41 AM

Just about a week ago, my youngest child, Hadley, had surgery to remove her tonsils and adenoids. The day before surgery, the doctor's office called me to collect $511.25, which was our patient responsibility. The woman from billing was taken back when I asked "Is everyone in Anthem's network?" She even chuckled like, "Will it change anything if someone is?"

Truthfully, it probably wouldn't have changed our mind about getting the surgery, but I certainly would have negotiated a price ahead of time if they were. I know all too well about surprise billing and wanted to make sure I'm not being charged for out-of-network services at an in-network facility.

Recommended For You

Surprise medical bills in the mail months after a procedure takes place when an in-network doctor refers you to someone who is out-of-network. This big surprise happened to me years ago, when I gave birth to Hadley. My OB/GYN was in network, but the anesthesiologist was out-of-network and I didn't know that until a bill arrived months later. In North Carolina, out-of-network hospital-based anesthesiologists bill customers an average of 1020% more than Medicare reimbursements for the same services. Since out of network providers have no contractual agreements with a network, there is really no limit to what they can charge.

Sometimes, these providers will purposefully be out of network to abuse the dysfunctional system currently in place. It happens all the time with specialists, anesthesiologists and lab work. While the charges may cost you a lot at the moment, it also translates to significantly higher premiums overall for a medical plan; hence the need for it to be controlled.

In the closing days of 2020, Congress finally enacted and the President signed into law the No Surprises Act. This will provide new federal protections for the consumer against surprise medical bills. For two years, there was a congressional debate over how to tackle the issue and at times, it seemed it would be dead on arrival. Ironically though, surprise medical bills are not a problem for public programs like Medicare and Medicaid, because they prohibit balance billing.

The No Surprise Act has key protections to hold consumers harmless from egregious out-of-network charges. The new law takes effect for health plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2022 and it applies to nearly all private health plans offered by employers (including grandfathered group health plans and the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program), as well as non-group health insurance policies offered through and outside of the marketplace.

Rachel Miner is the founder and owner of Thrive Benefits LLC

NOT FOR REPRINT

© 2025 ALM Global, LLC, All Rights Reserved. Request academic re-use from www.copyright.com. All other uses, submit a request to [email protected]. For more information visit Asset & Logo Licensing.

By Alan Goforth | April 21, 2025

The executive order was praised by an unlikely source – Mark Cuban, who started Cost Plus Drugs in 2022 in an attempt to control prices through direct-to-consumer transparency.

Mark Cuban praises Trump's PBM executive order, predicts 'hundreds of billions' in savings

By Caitlin Moling | April 18, 2025

The growing chasm in customer experience begs the question: What are the top health plans doing well that the lowest-ranked plans cannot seem to get right?

Poor communication fuels health plan dissatisfaction

By Lily Peterson | April 18, 2025

"We are seeing change rapidly with the increasingly high annual maximums being offered in the market and as brokers become more aware of the true value received when members access preferred pricing for services at the dentist through network discounts provided by their insurance," says Sam Melamed.

The future of stand alone dental insurance: A Q&A with Sam Melamed
The Insider's Guide to Reliable Provider Directories for Brokerages and FMOs link

Guide

Sponsored by Zelis

The accuracy of your provider directories is vital to shaping your success. The guide provides actionable insights and best practices for ensuring the data you rely on is precise and trustworthy.

How One Employer Helped 1 in 3 Employees Improve Blood Pressure link

Case Study

Sponsored by Labcorp

High blood pressure affects nearly half of U.S. adults, increasing the risk of heart disease and stroke. This case study explores how an employer-sponsored wellness program helped approximately 1 in 3 employees improve their blood pressure risk level.

Reducing Employee Onboarding Time and Solving Staffing Challenges link

Case Study

Sponsored by Labcorp

Long onboarding times and staffing shortages create costly delays. Discover how one large healthcare system streamlined its hiring process, reducing onboarding time from weeks to days while improving the candidate experience and freeing up internal staff.